Commentary

Commentary: Lex Leifheit

Westside Halloween and S.F. Urbanism

San Francisco’s urban conversation tends to focus on downtown nightlife, restaurants, entertainment and major cultural institutions. But each October, the west side reveals another kind of nighttime city: families walking, neighbors gathering, illuminated homes and block parties. The Sunset, Parkside and Richmond neighborhoods come alive, with October traditions like BalBOOa Fright Fest, Movies in McCoppin, ScareGrove and The Great Hauntway. Notably, nearly every event is family-friendly.

Most of these offerings didn’t begin with a high ticket price, government or philanthropic funding. They began with the volunteer efforts of a few neighbors and shop owners.

For many, the grassroots nature of things is half the fun. It leaves room for spontaneity, gives local merchants a visible and useful role, and creates a feeling of belonging. The result is a kind of mixed-use mischief: residential streets, shop windows, parks and schoolyards taking on new purposes for a few hours.

Sunset families remember Playland on 43rd Avenue, where kids gathered before trick-or-treating in the surrounding neighborhood. What began organically and grew so popular that it later included politicians, a street closure and traffic guides. The event’s evolution offered useful lessons: good civic events often start small, then earn the support and structure needed to welcome more people safely.

What makes an urban event family-friendly? One neighbor put it bluntly—“my ideal event is one where I can safely ignore my child.” A slight exaggeration perhaps, but her point is important. Kid safety isn’t something San Franciscans take for granted. Locals are constantly assessing traffic, sightline, crowds and the availability of a quick retreat to a quieter place.

She went on to describe a broader challenge that rings true citywide: the challenge of repurposing space for something other than what it was built for. A parking lot can become a pumpkin patch. A park meadow can become a movie theater. A street designed to move cars can become a block party or festival route. A small commercial plaza can become a place where toddlers, teenagers and grandparents all feel welcome. This doesn’t happen automatically. It requires planning, communication, ingenuity and some degree of tolerance for an inevitable learning curve.

In speaking with neighbors for this column, a few suggestions came up repeatedly.

First, provide places to linger comfortably and affordably. Benches and tables, shade and bathrooms help people stay, spend and socialize. Post-pandemic, many westside residents have adapted to outdoor social life, bringing portable chairs and waterproof picnic blankets to events like the Pomeroy Pumpkin Patch movie night. Comfort is not an amenity added after the fact, it is part of the invitation and explicit in the design.

Second, manage big moments. Clear, realistic information about when key activities are happening goes a long way for people navigating food, nap or restroom breaks. It also helps people who prefer more structure, or less stimulation, decide when to participate.

Third, pay attention to confident, safe mobility. Slow traffic, visible crossings and protected pathways help people feel comfortable and confident as they arrive, whether it’s via bike, bus, car, stroller or wheelchair. A welcoming event begins before anyone reaches the entrance.

Family-oriented urbanism stands to benefit everyone, economically speaking. The Urban Institute’s “Case and Means for Family-Friendly Core Cities” argues that cities cannot overly rely indefinitely on young, childless adult workers to fuel economic vitality. Changing demographics, low birthrates and new work patterns are challenging that model. A more socioeconomically diverse population of young people can strengthen workforce stability and create a virtuous cycle of people using schools, parks and other civic infrastructure.

That does not mean abandoning existing populations. It means recalibrating with a coordinated package of housing, education, safety and care infrastructure – competitive not in absolute terms, but relative to the surrounding area.

San Francisco’s “This Is Your City: 2026 Family Listening Series” is a promising step. With 13 city agency partners, an online survey and 14 in-person sessions, including family summits in the Richmond and Sunset, it recognizes that family life is connected to health, housing, recreation, education and economic development.

The west side’s Halloween lesson is simple: families do not need a city built only for them. They need a city that makes room for them, often by letting familiar places become something new. Sometimes that transformation begins with a few neighbors, some folding chairs and a little mixed-use mischief.

Lex Leifheit is an urbanist and writer focused on how cities shape everyday life, community and belonging. She lives in the Sunset District with her family.

Leave a Reply