emergency preparedness

Led by Sunset Supe, the City Debates Fate of Emergency Siren Use

By Thomas K. Pendergast

District 4 Supervisor Alan Wong and a Civil Grand Jury (CGJ) are both calling upon S.F. Mayor Daniel Lurie to decide whether the sirens of the outdoor public warning system will sing again or be silenced forever.

Initially constructed during World War II to warn of Japanese air raids, the 119 sirens located throughout the City continued operating through the Cold War era to alert San Franciscans about incoming ICBM nuclear missile attacks, until eventually they were taken offline in December 2019 due to cybersecurity concerns.

The decision followed a hacking incident in Dallas, Texas, where all 156 emergency sirens were activated shortly before midnight on a Friday and sounded for 90 minutes, causing widespread confusion.

A CGJ report notes that the City has changed much and so have the threats it faces. Instead of air raids and nuclear attacks, tsunamis, earthquakes, fires or terrorist attacks are far more likely to require immediate attention.

Furthermore, the CGJ report mentions that from 2005 onward the sirens were activated only once for an actual emergency, to warn of unsafe drinking water on Treasure Island, and several installations have been removed because “dilapidated hardware was in danger of falling and causing injury.”

One of the City’s emergency sirens can be seen near Sunset Boulevard. Photo by Thomas K. Pendergast.

The CGJ urged the mayor to decide, one way or the other.

“The Jury recommends that Department of Emergency Management (DEM) formally advise the Mayor and Board of Supervisors on whether to restore or permanently retire the Outdoor Public Warning System (OPWS), so that elected leadership can make an informed policy decision along with a public commitment.

“The DEM should make available a clear, up-to-date explanation of San Francisco’s emergency alerting strategy.

“Remnant siren hardware that presents a physical hazard should be removed, and one installation should be preserved as a public safety monument. DEM does difficult work with limited resources. Closing the siren question frees the department to focus its full attention on the systems and practices that directly protect residents and visitors every day.”

Wong said he agrees that something needs to be done, but not what the jury recommends. He pushed through a resolution early this year urging the mayor to restore funding and get the system up and running again.

“An operational outdoor public warning system is a valuable tool for alerting residents and visitors to imminent dangers, including tsunamis, earthquakes and other emergencies, particularly when cell-phone-based alerts may be insufficient,” the resolution states. “The Board of Supervisors urges the Capital Planning Committee to identify funding for restoration of the outdoor public warning system, beginning with sirens in tsunami evacuation zones and coastal areas, through unallocated Earthquake Safety and Emergency Response (ESER) bond funds or other existing emergency preparedness resources.”

The Geographic Information System shows the westside tsunami zone stretches from the north end of Ocean Beach at Balboa Street all the way south to the San Francisco Zoo. The zoo in particular is vulnerable, with most of it included in the Tsunami Evacuation and Inundation Zones.

Further north that zone goes as far inland as 46th Avenue between Moraga Avenue and Quintara Street, and in Golden Gate Park the soccer fields and Beach Chalet restaurant are also included within it.

“The Board of Supervisors urges the Department of Emergency Management and Department of Technology to develop and present a plan and timeline for restoration of the system, prioritizing tsunami evacuation zones and coastal areas; and … supports the restoration of the outdoor public warning system as an important component of a comprehensive emergency alert strategy for protecting the lives and safety of San Francisco residents, workers and visitors, and that further delay in addressing this critical infrastructure gap is unacceptable,” the resolution continues.

But the CGJ contends that modern technology provides much better alternatives to the old sirens wailing like banshees.

“For tsunamis, the threat San Franciscans most commonly associate with the need for sirens, the warning window can range from minutes to hours depending on the earthquake source location,” the CGJ states. “The December 2024 tsunami warning provided more than an hour of lead time before the estimated wave arrival. During that time, DEM used Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA), AlertSF, social media and mobile public address systems to reach the affected population.

“(Wong’s resolution) is supported by the expectation that a siren message would be available to everyone without any pre-arrangement,” the report elaborated. “Further support comes from the intuition that if sirens were once important in the past, their absence now must be a deficiency. Operational coastal sirens would not obviate the need for additional messaging systems to provide specific instructions: which evacuation phase, which areas, what to do and when it is safe to return. A siren tone cannot carry that information, and a spoken message is likely to be insufficient.”

But Wong’s resolution points out the shortcomings of those modern technologies, and the potential value of the screaming sirens.

“On Dec. 5, 2024, a 7.0 magnitude earthquake off the coast of Humboldt County triggered a tsunami warning for San Francisco, during which the City lacked a functional outdoor warning system to supplement cell phone alerts, requiring first responders to physically drive to Ocean Beach with loudspeakers to warn residents,” Wong’s resolution reads. “Cell-phone-based alerts, while useful, have significant limitations: they may not reach people who are sleeping, outdoors or in areas with poor cellular reception and they do not effectively reach tourists, unhoused residents, elderly individuals or others who may not have smartphones.”

“And the Dec. 20, 2025, power outage, which affected approximately 130,000 San Francisco customers for up to 48 hours, demonstrated the vulnerability of relying solely on cell phone-based emergency alerts, as residents’ phones lost battery power and with it, their ability to receive emergency notifications or contact 911.

“San Francisco’s AlertSF system, while valuable, has only approximately

195,000 subscribers out of more than 800,000 residents, leaving the majority of the population without opt-in emergency notifications,” the resolution states.

The resolution is now before Lurie’s office.

Leave a Reply