By Vickram Agarwal
For supporters of the Democratic Party, Nov. 3 was perhaps the best day politically of the past five years. Before the midterms, the party was expected to take back control of the House and most likely flip the Senate to a 51-seat majority. However, the blue wave came in much stronger than that. In Florida, Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) member Angie Nixon brought their Senate race within 3%. A DSA member without true party support or funding pushing the Republican stronghold into a close race was a signal for what was to come. The Democrats flipped seven Senate seats, including historic wins in Texas (first time in 38 years), Kansas (first time in 94 years) and Mississippi (first time in 44 years), three important Republican bastions. Here in San Francisco, California State Sen. Scott Wiener was elected to fill Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi’s seat. The electorate spoke. They wanted blue.
However, this is not all good news. Now, Democrats cannot just point fingers at President Donald Trump for all the country’s problems. They must solve them, and not doing so would be costly.
A primary reason for concern for Democrats should be the mandate that voters have just given them. Throughout many contentious states, voters were fed up with the economy and demanded change. The democrats promised that, and in turn gained the votes of perhaps millions of 2024 MAGA voters. Even with control over both chambers of Congress, enacting the change they want to see will be difficult. Not only is the party incredibly fractured (a topic for more discussion later), but Trump will not be too eager to let the Democrats push their agenda. After both chambers of Congress were officially blue, in an interview with Fox News, the president said he wouldn’t contest the results of the election (a major win for Democrats) and that he’d be happy to work with Democrats on certain topics such as immigration; however, if they were to try and push a bill that he didn’t like, he would happily veto it.
Following up on that comment, he posted a photo of a classic MAGA red hat with the writing “VETO” on it to Truth Social. In that same Fox News interview, he described how “after a couple of months of vetoes, they’ll go out, and they’ll say, ‘How do we get this stuff done?’ And we’ll work together.” Trump has historically been reluctant to work with democrats – when the Democrats had control over the House (but not the Senate) in the 116th Congress during Trump’s first term, it was one of the more unproductive sessions in American history. On top of that, the president now has zero incentive to work across the aisle; he is not up for re-election in 2028, and he has already shown that he does not care about the future of the party or anything beyond himself.
This is very bad news for the Democrats, especially those in states that have historically been red. Voters are expecting serious change, and after voting blue (for some, the first time in their lives), they expect the change they were promised. Yet, the Democrats don’t truly have the political ability to deliver upon the change they promised. In the past two elections, voters have shown how fickle they are, swinging from party to party depending on the state of the economy. If the Democrats do not fix the economy by 2028 (a large problem that they may struggle to fully fix), Republicans will blame it on the Democrats, and all the new voters the party gained could likely swing back. The voters gave Democrats the very same mandate they gave Republicans two years ago, and if the Democrats do not deliver, they will pay for it in 2028.
This would be a much easier problem to address if the party were unified. However, that could not be further from the case; in the past two years, the DSA and DSA-adjacent wing of the party have gained significant ground and are actively challenging the establishment Republicans. This cycle, they proved they could appeal to a red electorate (with wins in Maine and Michigan), along with bringing Florida within three points. The DSA wing argues that the established Democratic Party has no clear goals, policy or plans, while the establishment argues that the DSA wing is too extreme for most centrist voters. While both sides netted huge wins, they benefit the more radical DSA wing much more, serving as a proof of concept. These tensions will play out in the 2028 democratic primaries, with key players like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Kamala Harris and Jon Ossoff predicted to toss their hats in the ring.
However, the party has a much more immediate internal division: how to deal with the next two years. On Election Night, Rep. Robert Gargia (D-California), incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee, tweeted “LAWYER UP,” a reference to the many impeachment attempts that are sure to come. However, other Democrats such as James Talarico, the newly minted Texas Senator, have promised to reach across the aisle to solve the country’s problems. So, the party reaches an impasse – half want to spend the next two years targeting the president and the blatant corruption this country has been subject to, and the other half want to try to compromise to pass legislation. If the party wishes to compete in 2028, they cannot spend the next two years fighting each other.
Election Night was superb for Democrats. The next two years will test the party in ways it hasn’t been tested in a long time, forcing it to figure out its identity in a Post-Trump era of American Politics.
Vickram “Vick” Agarwal is a high-schooler born and raised in the Richmond District. He covers local news, community stories and sports, with an interest in the people and issues shaping the neighborhood. Outside of journalism, he enjoys playing soccer and following current events.
Categories: Commentary












